Il San Pietro di Positano

The MOST beautiful hotel I have ever stayed at!! The beauty of this hotel brought me to tears! We were blessed enough to have stayed here last summer and it has been in my dreams ever since! The staff and manager were so kind and friendly to my husband and I and to our two teenage daughters! We talk about our visit there all of the time and how we can’t wait to go back! I am blown away by the reviews with some of the negative comments ! While I respect their onions, I have to disagree and I hope that the hotel continues to keep it tranquil quiet so people can enjoy the beautiful sounds of nature and just relax!! One of the reasons we chose this hotel was because it’s secluded from the noise and chaos. I also could not have appreciated the beautiful soaps more and still have them set aside in their beautiful box. It was such a nice little gift and such a nice send off as we left what was the best property I have ever been to! Thank you to everyone at Il San Pietro! We will see you again soon!!❤️

Il San Pietro di Positano is undoubtedly one of the most stunning hotels in Italy, offering what is arguably the best view of all the top-tier hotels in the country. The panoramic vistas of the Amalfi Coast are simply breathtaking—so much so that they take your breath away the moment you step onto the terrace. The view alone makes this hotel worth visiting, a sight that you'll never forget. As expected from a hotel of this caliber, the service is impeccable. The staff is polite, friendly, and professional, adhering to the high standards one would anticipate at such an exclusive property. However, despite its undeniable beauty and exceptional location, there are a few drawbacks that, unfortunately, detract from the overall experience. One of the major issues is the atmosphere—or rather, the lack of it. The hotel’s outdoor bar is a lovely spot with a view, but there's a notable absence of music, which feels a bit strange for a luxury hotel. The silence makes it feel somewhat lifeless, and unless you're interested in complete peace and quiet, it's hard to relax in such an environment. In comparison, the Hotel Sirenuse, a direct competitor, offers a more vibrant and lively atmosphere, with music playing softly everywhere—whether live or from speakers—which makes it easier to unwind. Moreover, the hotel lacks any real sense of activity in the evenings. By 10:30 p.m., the only sound you’ll hear is the chirping of crickets. There's no entertainment or energy after dark, which can make the hotel feel a bit dull. While the restaurant does have some live music, the pianist only plays, without singing, which feels a little less engaging compared to other high-end hotels where live performers often sing along with their music. Another downside is that if you want to enjoy a drink or smoke an Icos, you’re left sitting in silence outside at the bar. It’s almost eerily quiet, and without any music or social ambiance, it can feel lonely and a bit sterile. Given the hotel’s steep price tag—nearly €15.000 for just three nights—it feels like a missed opportunity not to offer a more vibrant and enjoyable atmosphere in the evenings. In comparison, I felt much more relaxed and at ease at Hotel Sirenuse, which provided a more dynamic and sociable environment, complete with soothing background music. In summary, while Il San Pietro di Positano is an objectively beautiful hotel with exceptional views and top-tier service, it falls short in providing the lively, engaging atmosphere that one might expect at such a luxury property. For that reason, I would rate it 3 out of 5. It's hard not to compare it to Sirenuse, where the overall experience—view, service, and ambiance—felt much more enjoyable.

We had the most enjoyable stay at Il San Pietro di Positano. Friendly and helpful staff, excellent food, exceptional design and decor, super comfortable beds, superb location. The views are stunning, like from a movie set. We can’t wait to be back!

We were absolutely blown away by ISP. We usually stay at Treville, a few hundred metres away towards Positano, but as they were closing for the season we moved to ISP. Treville dropped us off in their boat, and we made our way up the lift to reception. As soon as stepped out of the lift we immediately decided to extend our stay for another night. The views are simply extraordinary, and a we were fortunate to be upgraded to a suite with a wall of glass overlooking Positano. Even the shower and tub had the same panoramic view. The food was exquisite, both at the informal beach restaurant and their Michelin restaurant, Zass. Yes, it is expensive, but the food and drink prices are very reasonable for a hotel of this quality. The mini bar was included, and they even threw in lunch on the beach on the final day when they were closing. Throughout the stay, there was huge generosity of spirit, with the most charming staff, led by the best GM we have ever experienced running the show front and centre. It is unfair to compare ISP with Treville - they are both world class hotels. Treville is akin to staying with friends in their incredible private villa, whereas ISP is the full 5 star hotel package with facilities and restaurants to match. But both excel at service, with nothing too much trouble. We can’t wait to visit again!